Arcadia Homes Under $500K · Page 3

84 homes under $500K for sale in Arcadia, median asking price $240,000, mostly $149,000 – $405,000. Homes with an asking price under $500,000. ZIP 34266 (Arcadia, mostly DeSoto County). As of Oct 9, 2026.

401 CITRUS AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$310,000

401 CITRUS AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

4 bed
2 bath
1,248 sqft

MLS# A4700128 · Listing courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN

408 MAPLE STREET, ARCADIA
Active

$255,000

408 MAPLE STREET

ARCADIA, FL 34266

5 bed
2 bath
1,281 sqft

MLS# A4700131 · Listing courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN

523 LEE AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$350,000

523 LEE AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

4 bed
2 bath
3,716 sqft

MLS# N6144924 · Listing courtesy of SARASOTA REALTY ASSOC., INC.

5635 BRAHMA AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$229,000

5635 BRAHMA AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,629 sqft

MLS# B4902293 · Listing courtesy of FAITH AND FAMILY REALTY LLC

34 SEVILLA AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$292,000

34 SEVILLA AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,406 sqft

MLS# C7527776 · Listing courtesy of COLLINS MANAGEMENT

11604 SHELFER AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$449,000

11604 SHELFER AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,992 sqft

MLS# C7527406 · Listing courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC

1102 ARCADIA AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$315,000

1102 ARCADIA AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,462 sqft

MLS# A4697319 · Listing courtesy of TOWN & COUNTRY PROPERTIES OF FL

5587 HIGHWAY 17, ARCADIA
Active

$299,000

5587 HIGHWAY 17

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,442 sqft

MLS# C7527458 · Listing courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC

2798 LOVEJOY STREET, ARCADIA
Active Under Contract

$399,000

2798 LOVEJOY STREET

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,484 sqft

MLS# C7527105 · Listing courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC

1938 DUKE STREET, ARCADIA
Active

$253,000

1938 DUKE STREET

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,196 sqft

MLS# L4962676 · Listing courtesy of HELLOSOLD LLC

5549 SHORES AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$229,900

5549 SHORES AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

2 bed
1 bath
1,152 sqft

MLS# C7526813 · Listing courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC

7597 HIGHWAY 31, ARCADIA
Active Under Contract

$359,000

7597 HIGHWAY 31

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,161 sqft

MLS# D6147543 · Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 SUNBELT REALTY

9827 HOTH ROAD, ARCADIA
Active Under Contract

$365,000

9827 HOTH ROAD

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,344 sqft

MLS# A4694213 · Listing courtesy of TOWN & COUNTRY PROPERTIES OF FL

2403 POINTER AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$259,000

2403 POINTER AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,119 sqft

MLS# C7525175 · Listing courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC

1059 SUGAR BABE ROAD, ARCADIA
Active

$150,000

1059 SUGAR BABE ROAD

ARCADIA, FL 34266

2 bed
2 bath
960 sqft

MLS# A4690959 · Listing courtesy of TOWN & COUNTRY PROPERTIES OF FL

117 MANATEE AVENUE, ARCADIA
Pending

$123,000

117 MANATEE AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

1 bed
1 bath
512 sqft

MLS# A4691167 · Listing courtesy of TOWN & COUNTRY PROPERTIES OF FL

223 MONROE AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$410,000

223 MONROE AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
3 bath
2,491 sqft

MLS# A4689811 · Listing courtesy of TOWN & COUNTRY PROPERTIES OF FL

1620 HAVEN DRIVE, ARCADIA
Active

$379,000

1620 HAVEN DRIVE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

4 bed
2 bath
1,600 sqft

MLS# A4689134 · Listing courtesy of REMAX LANDMARK

1601 SHEILA DRIVE, ARCADIA
Active Under Contract

$349,999

1601 SHEILA DRIVE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,374 sqft

MLS# C7524451 · Listing courtesy of MARINA PARK REALTY LLC

213 MONROE AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$359,000

213 MONROE AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

4 bed
2 bath
2,128 sqft

MLS# TB8494239 · Listing courtesy of HOMECOIN.COM

1652 HARLEM CIRCLE, ARCADIA
Active

$175,900

1652 HARLEM CIRCLE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

2 bed
1 bath
915 sqft

MLS# A4689031 · Listing courtesy of DALTON WADE INC

114 SINGLETON AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active Under Contract

$119,500

114 SINGLETON AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

3 bed
2 bath
1,296 sqft

MLS# A4687908 · Listing courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS ISLAND LIFE REAL ESTATE

1142 MILDRED STREET, ARCADIA
Pending

$199,900

1142 MILDRED STREET

ARCADIA, FL 34266

2 bed
3 bath
1,611 sqft

MLS# C7524077 · Listing courtesy of ALLISON JAMES ESTATES & HOMES

1211 EUCALYPTUS AVENUE, ARCADIA
Active

$299,900

1211 EUCALYPTUS AVENUE

ARCADIA, FL 34266

1 bed
1 bath
576 sqft

MLS# A4685984 · Listing courtesy of RMZ REALTY INC.

More in Arcadia

Homes Under $500K nearby

Questions about Arcadia Homes Under $500K

How many homes under $500K are for sale in Arcadia?

84 homes under $500K are listed on this site as of Oct 9, 2026, from Stellar MLS. The list updates every hour.

What is the median asking price of homes under $500K in Arcadia?

The median asking price is $240,000; most are listed between $149,000 and $405,000. These are asking prices, not sale prices.

Can George help me buy in Arcadia?

Yes. George Predescu, REALTOR® with Horizon Realty International, can set up showings for any listing here, including ones listed by other brokers. Call or text (941) 899-3045.

Want to see one of these homes under $500K?

George Predescu, REALTOR® with Horizon Realty International, can answer questions and set up showings.

Call (941) 899-3045Text GeorgeSend a message

Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of Oct 9, 2026, 5:00 PM EDT. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Full IDX / DMCA disclaimer