434 TREMINGHAM WAY

Property Details

Description

Welcome to 434 Tremingham Way, an impressive custom estate in The Reserve, one of Venice’s most private residential enclaves. Positioned on a beautifully landscaped homesite overlooking the sixth tee of the Panther Course and directly across from Plantation Golf & Country Club, this nearly 3,800-square-foot residence combines generous proportions, elegant interiors and an extraordinary collection of recent improvements. More than $280,000 was invested during 2025, including a heated saltwater pool and spa, a new 3.5-car garage addition, interior renovations, and refreshed landscaping and hardscaping. The spacious living room features a vaulted ceiling, new electric fireplace, stone mantel and expansive views across the lanai to the golf course. The renovated kitchen offers extensive KraftMaid soft-close cabinetry, abundant storage and an easy connection to the living and dining areas. A dedicated wine bar with refrigerator creates an inviting gathering place for entertaining and a stepping stone to the intimate dining room with elegant vaulted ceiling. The primary suite opens to the lanai through French doors and includes two walk-in closets and a renovated marble bathroom. Generous guest accommodations, an updated guest bathroom, a renovated pool bath with outdoor access, and a vaulted office or den provide excellent flexibility and possibly a fourth bedroom. Fresh interior paint, new lighting and ceiling fans, plantation shutters and an electric privacy shade complete the interior. Outdoor living is at the heart of this property. The new heated saltwater pool and spa are surrounded by elegant light-toned shell pavers and enhanced by lighted water features, sheer descents and a bubbler. The Hayward OmniLogic system provides app-based control, while two independent pumps allow the pool, spa and fountains to operate simultaneously. Additional features include automatic water-fill and release functions, an outdoor shower, and a whole-house water shutoff with pool bypass. The expansive screened lanai enjoys peaceful fairway views and includes a unique interior garden. Easy-pull hurricane protection extends across the rear of the home, and all the side windows while impact windows protect the front. New enclosure screening and doors, tropical landscaping, privacy hedging and palms behind the pool cage create a secluded, resort-style setting. The new envy worthy 3.5-car garage addition features hurricane-rated doors and windows, a painted floor and walls, built-in storage and a refrigerator. An extended brick-paver driveway provides parking for up to eight vehicles. The Reserve is a gated neighborhood of fewer than 80 custom estate homes within the Plantation Golf & Country Club community. Its oversized homesites, ranging from approximately one-third to more than one-half acre, are known for deep setbacks, mature landscaping, golf and water views, and exceptional privacy. Residents enjoy low HOA fees and no CDD fees. Club membership is optional and provides access to two 18-hole championship courses designed by Ron Garl, a 45,000-square-foot clubhouse with dining and social activities, 12 Har-Tru tennis courts, pickleball, fitness facilities, and a Junior Olympic-size swimming pool and spa. Located minutes from Wellen Park, approximately 15 minutes from historic downtown Venice and the Gulf beaches, and convenient to I-75, estate-sized living, exceptional amenities and the best of the Southwest Florida lifestyle.

Facts & Costs

Property type

Single Family Residence

Year built

1991

Lot size

0.37 acres

Stories

1

Garage

3 spaces

Price per sq ft

$360

Days on market

24

Private pool

Yes

Waterfront

No

Community

The Reserve

Subdivision

THE RESERVE

County

Sarasota

Flood zone

X

Monthly & yearly costs

HOA fee

$1,350 / annually

Property taxes

$9,208 / year (2025)

As reported by the listing agent. Verify with the HOA and county.

Construction & systems

Heating

Electric

Cooling

Central Air, Zoned

Flooring

Carpet, Ceramic Tile, Luxury Vinyl, Marble

Roof

Tile

Construction

Block, Stucco

Parking

Driveway, Garage Faces Side, Golf Cart Parking, Guest, Off Street, Oversized

View

Golf Course

Payment Estimate

$7,706 / month

Principal & interest

$6,826

Property taxes

$767

HOA

$113

Home insurance

enter below

Estimate only, not a loan offer. Rate is a starting value; taxes and HOA are as reported by the listing agent. Florida insurance (including flood) varies widely. Ask George for a lender referral.

Location

Features & Amenities

• Built-In Oven
• Cooktop
• Dishwasher
• Disposal
• Dryer
• Microwave
• Range Hood
• Washer
• Wine Refrigerator
• Built-in Features
• Ceiling Fans(s)
• Crown Molding
• Dry Bar
• Eat-in Kitchen
• High Ceilings
• Primary Bedroom Main Floor
• Solid Wood Cabinets
• Stone Counters
• Tray Ceiling(s)
• Walk-In Closet(s)
• Window Treatments
• Hurricane Shutters
• Lighting
• Outdoor Shower
• Rain Gutters
• Heated
• In Ground
• Salt Water
• Screen Enclosure