2417 CASEY KEY ROAD

Property Details

Description

A rare Gulf-to-Bay opportunity on Casey Key, where nearly an acre of land stretches from the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico to the protected waters of the bay. With just over 100 feet of water frontage on both the Gulf and bay sides (and more than 400-feet of depth), this exceptional property presents an opportunity to create a custom waterfront retreat tailored entirely to your vision. Set along one of Sarasota’s most coveted barrier islands, the expansive homesite offers the extraordinary combination of a private Gulf beach, spectacular sunset views and direct boating access—all from one property. On the beach side, step directly onto your own stretch of walkable sandy shoreline and enjoy unobstructed views across the Gulf of Mexico. Approximately 104 feet of Gulf frontage and a newer seawall, completed in 2004, establish an impressive setting for a future coastal residence designed around the water, sunsets and relaxed Casey Key lifestyle. Mature tropical landscaping and the parcel’s generous proportions create a wonderful sense of privacy rarely found along the coast. Across the property, approximately 104 feet of bay frontage opens another dimension of waterfront living. The dock and boat lift, both added in 2022, provide convenient access to the Intracoastal Waterway and the exceptional boating, fishing and cruising opportunities of Southwest Florida. Spend the morning on the boat, return home by water and finish the day watching the sun disappear into the Gulf from your own backyard. The nearly one-acre parcel provides remarkable flexibility for designing a custom residence that takes full advantage of its Gulf-to-Bay orientation, with the potential to capture water views in both directions. Imagine expansive indoor-outdoor living spaces, elevated terraces, a resort-style pool environment and private gathering areas framed by tropical landscaping—all designed specifically around this extraordinary coastal setting. Casey Key remains one of the Gulf Coast’s most distinctive residential enclaves, prized for its natural beauty, privacy and laid-back character. Yet this secluded island setting is remarkably convenient to the restaurants, boutiques and waterfront charm of Nokomis and Venice, as well as nearby Nokomis Beach, the North Jetty, Venice Island and the Legacy Trail. Downtown Sarasota’s cultural attractions, dining and shopping are also within comfortable reach, while the Intracoastal and Gulf of Mexico are quite literally at your doorstep. 2417 Casey Key Road is more than a waterfront homesite—it is an opportunity to create a legacy property on one of Southwest Florida’s most treasured barrier islands, with the Gulf at one door and the bay at the other.

Facts & Costs

Property type

Single Family Residence

Year built

1967

Lot size

0.88 acres

Stories

1

Price per sq ft

$3,231

Days on market

23

Private pool

No

Waterfront

Yes

Community

Casey Key

Subdivision

CASEY KEY

County

Sarasota

Flood zone

AO

Monthly & yearly costs

Property taxes

$39,571 / year (2025)

As reported by the listing agent. Verify with the HOA and county.

Construction & systems

Heating

Central, Electric

Cooling

Central Air

Flooring

Terrazzo

Roof

Shingle

Construction

Stucco, Frame

Parking

Circular Driveway, Driveway

View

Gulf/Ocean - Full

Payment Estimate

$27,544 / month

Principal & interest

$24,246

Property taxes

$3,298

HOA

$0

Home insurance

enter below

Estimate only, not a loan offer. Rate is a starting value; taxes and HOA are as reported by the listing agent. Florida insurance (including flood) varies widely. Ask George for a lender referral.

Location

Features & Amenities

• Dishwasher
• Disposal
• Electric Water Heater
• Range
• Refrigerator
• Washer
• Living Room/Dining Room Combo
• Open Floorplan
• Solid Surface Counters
• Private Entrance
• Private Mailbox
• Bay/Harbor
• Gulf/Ocean