4511 BAY SHORE ROAD

Property Details

Description

Nestled on 1.1 acres of pristine bayfront along Sarasota Bay, Etowah stands as a timeless icon of Sarasota’s rich architectural heritage, offering sweeping, wide-open bay views to the north and south, from the manicured lawn at the water’s edge all the way to the distant skyline of downtown Sarasota, with glowing sunset views that unfold nightly across the horizon. Originally built in 1925, this distinguished two-story Mediterranean Revival estate spans over 6,500 square feet and commands captivating views across the bay, all while being just 10 minutes from downtown Sarasota. Following an extensive year-long restoration, Etowah has been meticulously renewed from the inside out. Every major system of the home has been comprehensively replaced or upgraded, including all new electrical, plumbing, heating and air-conditioning systems, roofing, insulation, and drywall, ensuring modern performance while preserving historic integrity. A significant west-side addition by renowned local architect Frank Folsom Smith in 1992 introduced a gracious primary suite, a sophisticated bar area, and a grand great room—enhancements that seamlessly complement the home’s historic character. Upon entry, a vaulted ceiling sets a dramatic and welcoming tone, guiding you into the formal living room anchored by the home’s original fireplace. The adjacent dining room, surrounded by windows crafted with original glass sourced from the nearby Ringling era, creates an extraordinary setting for entertaining and comfortably accommodates gatherings of 12 or more. Designed for both elegance and performance, the chef’s kitchen is outfitted with top-of-the-line Thermador appliances, a Sub-Zero refrigerator, and every modern convenience, while the sun-filled eat-in area offers the perfect spot for morning coffee overlooking the grounds. The west wing of the home unfolds around a serene courtyard, with the great room and owner’s suite positioned on either side—creating a seamless indoor-outdoor living experience. The owner’s suite features sweeping bay views, dual walk-in closets, and a spacious spa-like bath. Upstairs, a second primary bedroom offers its own wood-burning fireplace, picturesque bay vistas, and generous closet space. 3 additional bedrooms on this level are well-proportioned and thoughtfully laid out, complemented by a sunken office or den tucked quietly at the end of the hall. The grounds are equally exceptional, highlighted by a heated, resort-style 15’ x 50’ swimming pool—perfect for both relaxation and entertaining. Completing the waterfront setting is a 4’ x 50’ dock, providing direct access to Sarasota Bay for boating, paddleboarding, and waterfront enjoyment. Completing the property is the original detached garage with an adjoining workshop, gardening space, laundry facilities, and private guest quarters—ideal for visitors or staff. A rare offering of architectural significance and modern luxury, Etowah is a one-of-a-kind estate that seamlessly bridges historic Florida elegance with contemporary living, all set against the unparalleled beauty of Sarasota Bay.

Facts & Costs

Property type

Single Family Residence

Year built

1928

Lot size

1.1 acres

Stories

2

Garage

2 spaces

Half baths

2

Price per sq ft

$1,376

Days on market

259

Private pool

Yes

Waterfront

Yes

Community

Indian Beach

Subdivision

INDIAN BEACH

County

Sarasota

Flood zone

VE

Monthly & yearly costs

Property taxes

$46,124 / year (2025)

As reported by the listing agent. Verify with the HOA and county.

Construction & systems

Heating

Central, Electric

Cooling

Central Air, Zoned

Flooring

Carpet, Tile, Wood

Roof

Tile

Construction

Block, Stucco

Parking

Circular Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Garage Faces Side, Guest, Workshop in Garage

View

City, Pool, Trees/Woods, Water

Payment Estimate

$44,271 / month

Principal & interest

$40,427

Property taxes

$3,844

HOA

$0

Home insurance

enter below

Estimate only, not a loan offer. Rate is a starting value; taxes and HOA are as reported by the listing agent. Florida insurance (including flood) varies widely. Ask George for a lender referral.

Location

Features & Amenities

• Bar Fridge
• Built-In Oven
• Convection Oven
• Cooktop
• Dishwasher
• Disposal
• Dryer
• Electric Water Heater
• Exhaust Fan
• Freezer
• Microwave
• Refrigerator
• Washer
• Built-in Features
• Ceiling Fans(s)
• Crown Molding
• Eat-in Kitchen
• High Ceilings
• Open Floorplan
• Pest Guard System
• Primary Bedroom Main Floor
• Solid Surface Counters
• Solid Wood Cabinets
• Split Bedroom
• Stone Counters
• Vaulted Ceiling(s)
• Walk-In Closet(s)
• Wet Bar
• Balcony
• Courtyard
• Dog Run
• Garden
• Lighting
• Outdoor Shower
• Auto Cleaner
• Child Safety Fence
• Heated
• In Ground
• Lap
• Outside Bath Access
• Pool Alarm
• Salt Water
• Self Cleaning
• Bay/Harbor
• Intracoastal Waterway